What Makes a Good Historical Fiction: Unraveling the Untold

Photo by Yogendra Singh on Unsplash
Are you a book lover – an enthusiast with a sense of inquisitiveness, particularly on historical fiction? Whether you want to write or read one in this genre, before we begin with such, we want to know what makes a good historical fiction.
Especially for aspiring writers or authors partaking in historical fiction as their main forte, we desire to write an engaging book – a good one, for that matter.
An example of the best historical fiction book set in New England is authored by Pamela Roberts Lee. She masterfully crafted the book entitled The Darkness at Dawn, which conveys the signs of an engaging historical fiction. It follows the story of John Lee, a 13-year-old boy, and Richard Hawkes, a 19-year-old petty thief and murderer, and how a severe conflict sparked between them.
It began when John witnessed Richard steal the church’s gold inlaid silver chalice. The next day turned around, and Richard threatened John to keep the theft a secret; otherwise, he would harm Grace, one of the significant people in His life. A dramatic end fell upon Richard and John – Richard was seated in a murder trial because John revealed the truth about the stolen chalice. John Lee finally stuck to what was truly right, cutting the thread of Richard Hawkes’s vile acts.
The Darkness at Dawn undeniably showcases the beauty of historical fiction and how history ingrained in fiction leaves an invaluable mark on readers.
Now that we have garnered a quick, fascinating glimpse of a good historical fiction, let’s finally unravel what makes it that good and engaging.
What Makes a Good Historical Fiction? Let’s Find Out!

Photo by Chris Lawton on Unsplash
A good historical fiction ties in with a compelling storytelling with accurate historical details, believable characters, captivating plot, vivid setting, satisfying conflict and resolution, profound theme and message, and balanced perspective, ultimately creating an engaging experience for the reader.
Historical Accuracy and Research
A good historical fiction should be grounded in historical facts and details. While it is fiction, tons of elements in history lean more on the factual side – the realities of the past. Thus, it is important to demonstrate thorough research into the period it portrays to make the story more immersing.
Believable Characters
Characters are the driving forces of a good story. Without them, what’s to tell? To make historical fiction a good and engaging one, it is crucial to imbue the characters with a sense of authenticity and relatability. We can tell if it’s a good book when the characters feel real and human enough for readers to resonate and connect with them in a special way.
Engaging Plot
A good plot is the bedrock of a good story. The story should be captivating and suspenseful, drawing readers in with excitement and thrill. The narrative should be compelling and portray a well-developed plot to immerse readers, not just in the beginning but until the end.
Vivid Setting
The historical setting is a critical aspect of historical fiction. It’s best to note that a vivid setting is superior. Thus, it should be richly described, bringing the past to life through detailed descriptions of the time period’s culture, customs, and environment. A good and vivid setting is far more immersive, offering readers an experience like no other.

Photo by Cristina Gottardi on Unsplash
Conflict and Resolution
These two aspects of a story fuel excitement among readers. Every good story requires conflict, whether internal or external, which ultimately drives the narrative. An enticing conflict leads to a satisfying resolution that will keep the readers fulfilled in their historical reading endeavors.
Theme and Message
Of course, the story’s theme and message are what supplies invaluable insights into the human experience. Without a central theme or an insightful message, it defeats the purpose of good historical fiction. The beautiful blend of theme and message provides a deeper understanding of history and its impact. Two of such tell a worthwhile narrative with deep meaning and purpose.
Balanced Perspective
Balance is indeed the key. A good historical fiction should strive to present a balanced and nuanced view of the past. Hence, it must avoid overly romanticized or simplistic portrayals. At the end of the day, when it comes to an engaging historical fiction, it is essential to balance history and story.
Finally, if you are interested (which I know for sure that you are) to get a hold of Pamela Roberts Lee’s The Darkness at Dawn, then go ahead and visit the author’s website to obtain a copy, or you can directly purchase on Amazon.
Experience what it’s like to immerse yourself in good historical fiction through this compelling and exceptional book. While you’re at it, you can also read another interesting article about the role of historical fiction in preserving memory.
Why Historical Fiction Matters for Understanding History
Photo by Tima Miroshnichenko When it comes to understanding history, why historical fiction matters is often overlooked in favor of textbooks and academic journals. While these sources provide facts and dates, historical fiction offers a more immersive and emotional...
Why Is Betrayal Important in Literature? The Ultimate Conflict
Photo by Haroon Ameer on Unsplash Where there are promises, there is space for betrayal. Themes about trust and betrayal are among the most common cruces in literature, and the primary reason for this is their beauty. It’s a calloused source of interest, but there’s...
Betrayal and Moral Dilemmas: Choices That Shape Destiny
Closed doors you can choose, depicting betrayal and moral dilemmas | Photo by Pixabay Just as oaths are sacred in Puritan religion, so is John Lee’s sworn promise to Richard Hawkes—a vow that haunts him for decades. Set in 1634, “The Darkness at Dawn” by Pamela...
0 Comments